Third-Party vs. In-House Testing: The Value of Independent Flexible Packaging Validation
For flexible packaging manufacturers and brands, ensuring the structural integrity, barrier performance, and safety of a package is non-negotiable. When a film fails—whether through delamination, poor seal strength, or compromised barrier properties—the resulting product loss and brand damage can be catastrophic.
To mitigate these risks, companies must rigorously test their materials. However, this raises a critical strategic question: Is it better to invest in an in-house testing laboratory, or partner with an independent, third-party testing facility, such as Flex-Pack Engineering?
While in-house capabilities have their place, relying on an independent laboratory provides unmatched benefits in unbiased validation, advanced analytical expertise, consultative recommendations and strict ASTM/ISO compliance.
The Role and Limitations of In-House Testing
Many packaging converters and large consumer packaged goods (CPG) companies maintain basic in-house testing capabilities. In-house labs are excellent for day-to-day Quality Assurance (QA) and rapid spot-checking during a production run. Measuring basic thickness, performing simple tensile tests, or checking visual defects on the line are highly efficient when done internally.
However, the limitations of in-house testing quickly become apparent when dealing with complex failures, reverse engineering, or the development of new film structures.
- Capital Expenditure: Advanced testing equipment for Differential Scanning Calorimetry (DSC), Oxygen Transmission Rate (OTR), and Moisture Vapor Transmission Rate (MVTR) requires a massive upfront capital investment.
- Maintenance and Calibration: Test results are only as good as the calibration of the equipment. Maintaining strict environmental controls and recalibrating sensitive instruments is an ongoing, hidden cost.
- Internal Bias: When a production team tests its own materials, there is an inherent risk of confirmation bias. In-house teams may unintentionally overlook foundational flaws when under pressure to meet production deadlines.
The Strategic Benefits of Third-Party Testing
Partnering with an independent laboratory like Flex-Pack Engineering shifts the burden of equipment maintenance and specialized staffing off your balance sheet while providing several core advantages:
- Unbiased, Objective Validation
In the event of a material failure or a dispute between a supplier and a buyer, an internal lab report often carries little weight. A third-party laboratory provides an impartial, scientifically sound analysis. This unbiased data is critical for resolving supply chain disputes, validating a new supplier’s claims, or proving that a down-gauged film meets the required Fitness for Use (FFU) criteria.
- Access to Advanced Equipment and Engineering Expertise
Purchasing a DSC or permeation testing machine is only half the equation; you must also have the engineering expertise to interpret the data. Third-party labs live and breathe flexible packaging. At Flex-Pack Engineering, we don’t just hand over a spreadsheet of raw data. We interpret the results, explain why a failure occurred, and provide actionable consulting to solve the compounding or structural issue.
- Strict ASTM and ISO Certification Standards
To ensure that testing data is universally accepted and accurate, tests must be performed according to strict ASTM (American Society for Testing and Materials) or ISO (International Organization for Standardization) protocols. Independent labs are built around these standard operating procedures, guaranteeing that every OTR, MVTR, or OIT (Oxidation Induction Time) test is performed flawlessly.
- Cost-Effective Innovation
When engineering a new sustainable film or integrating smart packaging technologies, the R&D testing requirements spike. Utilizing a third-party lab allows you to scale your testing needs up or down without hiring full-time analytical chemists or purchasing expensive machinery that may sit idle once the R&D phase is complete.
Finding the Right Synergy
The most successful flexible packaging operations utilize a hybrid approach. They rely on their in-house teams for routine line checks and basic QA, but they seamlessly integrate a third-party engineering laboratory for advanced analytical testing, failure analysis, and new product development.
How Flex-Pack Engineering Can Help
Flex-Pack Engineering offers a comprehensive suite of analytical and physical testing services, backed by expert consulting. We help you move beyond the “pass/fail” metrics of standard QA to truly understand the chemical and mechanical properties of your flexible films.
Whether you need unbiased ASTM/ISO testing for a new product launch, or require deep-dive failure analysis to troubleshoot a production issue, our fully equipped laboratory is ready to act as an extension of your engineering team.
Call Flex-Pack Engineering today at 888-300-1482 to discuss your flexible packaging testing requirements.










